CISO Voice

AI & Security / News

‘There is not much time to act’ Experts say the AI cyber threat is overblown – as OpenAI issues a new warning for the industry

A new report says doom-and-gloom AI warnings ‘start from a false premise about what drives the behavior of cybercriminals.’

Alex Blake
Alex Blake Cybersecurity Journalist · August 28, 2026 · 4 min read
OpenAI

AI is not the cybercrime bonanza we might think it is. That’s the conclusion of the UK’s Royal United Services Institute (RUSI) defense think tank, which recently published a report declaring that doomsday scenarios of cyber defenses being overrun by an army of unstoppable AI hackers “start from a false premise about what drives the behavior of cybercriminals.”

Key to RUSI’s argument is the assertion that, by and large, cybercriminals are not particularly innovative. Instead, thanks to an “effectively unlimited” pool of potential victims, they “generally use what works and stick with it.” As the saying goes, “if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it.”

RUSI stated that this approach comes down to threat actors’ primary motivation: money. If a technique keeps the cash rolling in, hackers will continue to use it, and “innovation only occurs when it increases profit or restores profitability after measures (such as increased resilience) systematically reduce returns,” RUSI argued.

The paper used ransomware as an example, pointing out that its rise in the 2010s did not occur because cybercriminals adopted untapped technologies, but rather because they adapted existing tech in new ways. The main motivator was, as always, to make money, RUSI said. By shaping known techniques into what became ransomware, hackers found novel ways to do that.

This reflects a sentiment we’ve seen before. Speaking to CISO Voice in July 2026, Martin Zugec, Technical Solutions Director at Bitdefender, said that hackers are “economically rational, and they reach for the cheapest thing that works. Most of the time, that is not AI … If AI ever becomes the cheapest, most reliable path to their objective, they will use it. Until then, be careful not to build your defenses around the version of the threat that makes better headlines than it does economics.”

Writing on LinkedIn, Ciaran Martin, Professor of Practice at the University of Oxford’s Blavatnik School of Government, and a Distinguished Fellow of RUSI, described the report as “badly needed.” He added that the demonstration of AI hacking abilities by the likes of Anthropic and OpenAI “doesn’t mean they automatically come into widespread use by malicious hackers in the way they’ve been disclosed.”

Sam Altman speaks out

Yet OpenAI itself has cautioned that AI poses a significant danger to governments, businesses and institutions, warning in an open letter signed by hundreds of leading cybersecurity companies that the world has “a limited window to strengthen cyber defenses.”

The letter portrayed hackers’ increasing use of dangerous AI models as inevitable, saying that critical infrastructure like hospitals and water treatment plants are at risk of falling victim. At the same time, the letter asserted that “AI advances are already giving defenders new ways to fix weaknesses that have accumulated over years.”

The signatories — which included notable names such as Cloudflare, Anthropic, Google, Microsoft, Oracle and more — proposed a series of “principles for a collective response.” That included the contention that “status quo security won’t be enough” and that critical infrastructure defenders need “a surge in tools and resources.”

As well as that, OpenAI’s letter said that defensive teams should be empowered with “cyber-capable AI” that “brings specialist skills to defenders and makes core security tasks faster, cheaper and better.” It also advocated for a collective response “to raise security standards and find new solutions to emerging cyber threats.”

Writing on X, OpenAI CEO Sam Altman said that “this is a critically important moment for cyber defense with AI; there is not much time to act … only an urgent and intense collective response will work.”

Whether you see adversarial AI as an existential threat or an overblown danger that few hackers are using evidently depends on who you ask. But as the contrasting statements from RUSI and OpenAI suggest, it’s not something that your organization can simply ignore.

Alex Blake
Alex Blake Cybersecurity Journalist

Alex Blake is a freelance journalist who has been covering the tech world for over a decade. In that time he's interviewed Apple VPs, reviewed countless products and taken deep dives into the pressing issues of the day. You'll find his work at TechRadar, Macworld, PC Gamer, T3 and more.

Keep reading for free,
one signup unlocks everything

We'll send you the CISO Voice newsletter. Unsubscribe anytime.

More from CISO Voice

Sign up to CISO Voice, the free newsletter trusted by senior security leaders.

Secret Link